How to Choose Your First Dildo: Material, Size & Shape
Your first dildo should feel like an exciting discovery, not a guessing game. Here's how to find a comfortable, beginner-friendly fit in three simple steps.
Buying your first dildo should be exciting, not overwhelming. But with so many sizes, shapes, colors and materials on the shelf, it's easy to feel unsure where to start. The good news? Once you know what to look for, choosing the right fit becomes much easier.
This guide breaks down how to choose a dildo in three easy steps: material, size and shape. Whether you're interested in something small and smooth or curious about larger designs, here's what to consider before making your first purchase.
Choose a Body-Safe Material
Material affects how a dildo feels, how you clean it and how well it holds up over time.
For a first toy, high-quality silicone is often an excellent starting point. It's available in a wide variety of firmness levels, textures and designs. But silicone isn't your only option.
Silicone
Feel: Smooth, flexible, soft to firm.
Pros: Non-porous, durable, easy to clean and available in many shapes.
Keep in Mind: Water-based lubricant is a reliable choice. Check the manufacturer's guidance before pairing silicone toys with silicone-based lubricant.
Dual-Density Silicone
Feel: A firmer core with a softer exterior.
Pros: Combines structural support with a more cushioned outer layer.
Keep in Mind: These designs may cost more than single-density options.
Glass
Feel: Hard, sleek and smooth.
Pros: Non-porous and suitable for carefully controlled temperature variation when designed for intimate use.
Keep in Mind: Rigid and sometimes heavy. Inspect for cracks or chips before use.
Stainless Steel
Feel: Firm, weighty and polished.
Pros: Durable, non-porous and relatively easy to clean.
Keep in Mind: Has no flexibility, which may feel too intense for some beginners.
TPE / TPR
Feel: Soft, squishy and sometimes skin-like.
Pros: Often affordable and available in realistic textures.
Keep in Mind: Many formulations are porous, require careful maintenance and may need replacing sooner.
Find the Right Dildo Size
The best size isn't necessarily the biggest. It's the one that feels manageable and comfortable for your body.
When shopping for a dildo, pay attention to both insertable length and diameter. Girth often has a significant influence on comfort, so don't judge a toy by its length alone.
Insertable Length
The portion intended for insertion, excluding the base or handle. This may differ from total length.
Diameter & Girth
Diameter measures width across the toy. Girth or circumference measures around it. Check which measurement the product lists.
Personal Comfort
Consider what feels familiar and manageable. There isn't one universal size that works for every beginner.
What Size Should Beginners Start With?
Some beginners consider a diameter of approximately 1 to 1.5 inches, but the smaller end may be more approachable for someone with no prior experience. Others may prefer smaller options.
A moderate insertable length can offer flexibility, but you don't need to use the entire length of a toy. Choose based on comfort rather than trying to meet a particular measurement.
When Should You Consider a Larger Dildo?
Once you understand which sizes and sensations you enjoy, you may become curious about a large dildo or a thicker, more substantial design.
Increase size gradually, use an appropriate lubricant, and give yourself time to adjust. Never force insertion or continue through pain.
Pick a Shape & Style
Shape can make just as much difference as size. Here's how popular designs compare.
From lifelike textures to colorful, minimalist designs, there are plenty of options in our dildo collection. The right choice depends on the look, feel and functionality you're interested in.
Realistic Dildos
Designed to resemble anatomy, often with lifelike contours, veining and natural-looking colors. Great for shoppers who prefer a more realistic appearance and texture.
Smooth & Non-Realistic
Sleek, colorful and often minimalist. Smooth designs may be appealing if you're looking for something with fewer pronounced textures.
Curved & Targeted Designs
Gentle curves and shaped tips can help direct pressure toward different internal areas, depending on anatomy and positioning.
Vibrating & Thrusting Dildos
Add powered vibration or movement. Consider noise level, controls, waterproof rating and cleaning requirements when comparing models.
Suction Cup Bases
Designed to attach to compatible, smooth surfaces for additional positioning options. Always test the attachment before use.
Harness-Compatible Designs
Some dildos are designed to work with compatible harnesses. Check base dimensions and harness compatibility before buying.
Important: Choosing a Dildo for Anal Play
Any toy used for anal insertion needs a secure, sufficiently wide flared base or another manufacturer-approved retrieval design that prevents the toy from being drawn inside.
Not every suction cup or decorative base is suitable for anal use. Check the product's intended use, choose an appropriate size and use plenty of compatible lubricant.
Your First Dildo Shopping Checklist
Keep these basics in mind when comparing your options.
Before You Buy, Check For:
- Material: Quality, non-porous silicone, glass or stainless steel.
- Diameter: A width that feels approachable for your experience level.
- Insertable Length: A manageable size with room to control positioning.
- Shape: Smooth, realistic, curved or textured based on your preferences.
- Base: A secure, appropriate base for the toy's intended use.
- Lubricant: A compatible water-based lubricant is a versatile starting point.
- Care Instructions: Clear cleaning and storage guidance from the manufacturer.
How to Clean & Care for Your Dildo
Proper cleaning and storage help keep your toy in good condition.
Simple Dildo Care Basics
- Clean Before and After Use: Follow the manufacturer's directions. Many non-powered toys can be washed with warm water and mild, unscented soap.
- Sanitize Only When Appropriate: Some solid, non-powered silicone, glass and stainless-steel toys may allow additional sanitizing methods. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and never boil electronic toys.
- Use Compatible Lubricant: Water-based lubricants are broadly compatible with many toy materials. Always check individual product guidance.
- Store Separately: Keep toys clean, dry and protected from direct sunlight or extreme temperatures. Individual storage pouches can help.
- Practice Good Hygiene: Use a fresh condom when sharing toys between partners or switching between anal and vaginal use, and clean toys as directed.
Dildo Buying FAQ
What size dildo should a beginner get?
A smaller or moderate diameter is often easier to manage. Some beginners look at options around 1 to 1.5 inches in diameter, but there is no universal ideal size. Choose based on your comfort and experience.
Why is a silicone dildo a popular beginner choice?
Quality silicone is non-porous, durable and available in many firmness levels. It's relatively easy to clean and comes in a wide range of designs. Individual sensitivities can still occur.
Is a large or girthy dildo okay for beginners?
Larger sizes may be challenging for someone with limited experience. Starting smaller and increasing gradually is generally a more comfortable approach. Never force insertion or push through pain.
What's the difference between realistic and non-realistic dildos?
Realistic dildos mimic anatomical appearance and may include pronounced textures. Non-realistic designs often feature smoother surfaces, abstract shapes and colorful finishes.
Can I use a dildo for anal play?
Yes, if the product is specifically designed for anal insertion and has a secure flared base or another appropriate safety feature. Start with a manageable size and use sufficient compatible lubricant.
Find Your Perfect Fit at Fascinations
Choosing your first dildo comes down to three things: a quality material, a comfortable size and a shape that matches your curiosity. Explore our collection online or visit a Fascinations store for friendly, judgment-free guidance.
Shop All Dildos Shop Realistic Dildos Find a Store
